The Totally Subjective Best Picture Book Buying Guide Before Christmas

PictureBooks, not only good for reading. Copyright Y. Mes


I was talking to two of my friends during our recent playgroup about our children’s favorite picture books and how it can be difficult to decide which ones to get.

I have read around 650 picture books since the start of the year (yep, 650, you can check my Goodreads profile here) and have been obsessed with reading and writing picture books for a while, so, they felt that maybe I could come up with some suggestions.

Instead of sending them an email I decided to  turn it into a blog post for the greater good of humankind (aren’t I grand). And now they will have to read my blog, maybe even leave a comment. Thanks, Jo and Chantelle.

They were even coerced into an awful, I mean, awesome photo during our last playgroup session.

                                So here is my:


PictureYes, that’s us. Copyright Yvonne Mes

Totally Subjective Best Picture Book Buying Guide Before Christmas

We also talked about which picture books we find appealing as opposed to our kids.

It is interesting, no matter how much I try to push some of my favourite stories my children’s way, it just doesn’t work.
Me: “Let’s read ‘Where the Wild Things Are” 
Them: “Nope! Not that one!”
Not interested, ouch! It almost feels like a personal rebuke.

There are many reasons they do no like a particular book (yet)  they may not be cognitively ready for a story like that, or it doesn’t involve their favourite TV characters OR animal OR colour OR vehicle, and it may not appeal to their personality. Children can get really enamored by the same story for months, long after parents have tired of reading it.

So, my bedtime rule is, they can pick one or two stories each and so can I. That way they have discovered stories they wouldn’t have picked out themselves but ended up really liking (or NOT), and they have satisfied their need for repetition and getting to know a favourite story intimately while discovering new things on subsequent readings.
 
A few notes to go with the list:

  • As these are the picture books my 3 year old and I have loved through the year they are totally subjective AND,
  • Totally random, depending on what we have read in 2013 (they weren’t necessarily published in 2013), this includes some old favourites.
  • There are even a few shared favourites, bulls-eye!
  • I actually like most of the books in the kid’s column as well.
  • I am heavily influenced by illustrations as well as text, and only the books I felt worked well on both accounts have been included.
  • Click on the images for a link to Amazon where you get to look ‘inside’ for most books, which is a great feature. Don’t forget your local independent bookshops (I have listed some Brisbane stores at the end of the post). And if you want to try before you buy there is always the library.
  • Some of the books on my list are not suitable for young children. I will indicate this.
  • Picking these books really wasn’t easy, I left many fine beautifully told and illustrated books out, but decided to stick with 20 each.
  • There are many book I wish I had read but didn’t get to this year, so if your child’s or your favourite  picture book is not on the list, please leave a comment.



Best Picture Books Selected by my Three Year Old:

Picture

The Runaway Hug

Nick Bland
Freya Blackwood

Endless hugs back and forth after this book.



Picture

Goodnight, Goodnight Construction Site

Sherri Duskey Rinker
Tom Lichtenheld


You get to say goodnight to all their favourite machines.
Great for bedtime.

Picture

Stuck

Oliver Jeffers


It is funny!
 

Picture

Listen to My Trumpet

Mo Willems


Check out more of Mo Willems’ books, they are fun and short.

Picture

The Rain Train

Ella De Roo
Brian Lovelock

Our favourite!! Have read it for a year, almost every night to both boys.

Picture

I Want My Hat Back

Jon Klassen


Funny, short, with a visual twist.

Picture

Green Eggs and Ham

Dr. Seuss

Gosh, it does get tedious after a few readings, but they can’t get enough!

Picture

The Wheels on the Bus
(any variation, and there are many!)

Jeanne Willis
Adam Stower

Picture

Stomp!

Jeanne Willis
Paul Howard


Probably his second favourite. He can recite it.


Picture

Rattletrap Car

Phyllis Root
Jill Barton

Lovely rhyme, a whole lot of rattletrap fun.

Picture

Dinosaur vs. Bedtime

Bob Shea


Roar!





Picture

I’m Really Ever So Not Well

Lauren Child


But really you could read him any Charlie and Lola book and he would be happy. And he doesn’t even watch the series.

Picture

Harvey, the Boy who Couldn’t Fart

Matthew Johnstone

Let’s face it, which child doesn’t enjoy a good fart story.

Picture

The Story of the Little Mole who knew it was None of his Business

Werner Holzwarth
Wolf Erlbruch

That is not a hat, that is poo. Kids love poo.

Picture

Steam Train, Dream Train

Sherri Duskey Rinker
Tom Lichtenheld

Yes, another train story. Beautifully illustrated!

Picture

Harry and the Bucketful of Dinosaurs

Ian Whybrow
Adrian Reynolds

This is a series, and any of these books are fine by my son.

Picture

Wolf Won’t Bite!

Emily Gravett


Yes, it will!

Picture

I Wish That I Had Duck Feet

Theo. LeSieg
B Tobey

An oldie, also great as a reader when they are a little older.



Picture

Read to Tiger

S. J. Fore
R. W. Alley


Ahhhh.

Picture

Children Make Terrible Pets

Peter Brown


Children may make terrible pets, but it makes for a good story.

Best Picture Books Selected By Me:

Picture

The Runaway Hug

Nick Bland
Freya Blackwood

I also really like this illustrator, she is marvelous, well worth checking out other books she has illustrated.


Picture

No Room for a Mouse

Kyle Mewburn
Freya Blackwood

Lovely story. And there is that illustrator again!


Picture

Stuck

Oliver Jeffers

It is funny!


Picture

The Arrival

Shaun Tan

A wordless picture book.


This would be a challenge for young children, but is a wonderful story and sparks discussion about immigration.

Picture

The Rain Train

Ella De Roo
Brian Lovelock

This is what is know as a ‘quiet’ book. It is a soothing poem, great to wind down before bed time.


Picture

I Want My Hat Back

Jon Klassen


Funny, short, with a visual twist.

Picture

Flotsam

David Wiesner

Wordless.
Lovely story. A plot challenge for young ones, though they will love the illustrations.

Picture

Otto: The Autobiography of a Teddy Bear

Tomi Ungerer


Picture

Wilfrid Gordon McDonald Partridge

Mem Fox
Julie Vivas


This book made me cry, in a good way.

Picture

Herman and Rosie

Gus Gordon

My favourite picture book ‘du jour’.
I met the author/ illustrator, check out my previous post.

Picture

Dinosaur vs. Bedtime

Bob Shea




Picture

I’m Really Ever So Not Well

Lauren Child

Though it may get a bit tedious reading night after night. I quite enjoyed reading several stories starring these great sibling characters.


Picture

Tanglewood

Margaret Wild
Vivienne Goodman


A beautiful poignant feel-good story.

Picture

The Story of the Little Mole who knew it was None of his Business

Werner Holzwarth
Wolf Erlbruch

The English title is so PC, in The Netherlands they mention the word ‘poo’, not here, sigh.


Picture

Dillweed’s Revenge: A Deadly Dose of Magic

Florence Parry Heide
Carson Ellis

A dark picture book. Not for the little ones, there is some deadly revenge in this story. I love the illustrations.

Picture

Home

Narelle Oliver

Narelle Oliver lives in Brisbane and this is also where this book is set
AND it is a lovely story AND you will learn something.

Picture

The Dreadful Fluff

Aaron Blabey

A bit different, but fun.

Picture

The Dark

Lemony Snickett
Jon Klassen


A concept story, bit abstract for young children.

I simply adore Jon Klassen’s artwork.


Picture

One Cool Friend

Toni Buzzeo
David Small

I love that main character and the little twist at the end.

Picture

If You Want to See a Whale

Julie Fogliano
Erin Stead

Another ‘quiet’ book. A beautiful poem and delicate whimsical illustrations.

Posts created 57